When an employee at an Insperity client loses coverage, COBRA questions land fast: who sends the election notice, who collects the premium, and who is on the hook if a deadline slips. Using a PEO doesn’t erase your responsibilities, and the split between you and Insperity is set by your contract, not by assumption.
By the end of this guide you’ll have a written record of who does what for COBRA administration under your Insperity arrangement, a reporting routine for qualifying events, a deadline tracker, and a list of fee and exit questions to settle before renewal. Before you start, gather your client service agreement, your benefits plan documents, and your headcount history for the past year or two.
Step 1: Confirm Whether Federal COBRA or State Continuation Applies to Your Group
Federal COBRA generally applies to group health plans of employers that had 20 or more employees on a typical business day in the prior year. Smaller employers are often covered by state continuation laws, usually called mini-COBRA, and these vary by state in who qualifies, how long coverage lasts, and how notices work. Check the U.S. Department of Labor’s COBRA materials and your state insurance department’s guidance for the current rules.
A PEO adds a wrinkle. The headcount test and the governing rules depend on which plan counts as the group health plan for continuation purposes: a PEO-sponsored multiple-employer arrangement, or a plan sponsored by your company. Don’t guess. The answer can change which law applies and whose headcount is counted.
Do this now:
- Write down your worksite state or states.
- Write down the carrier or plan type your employees are enrolled in, using your benefits documents.
- Ask your Insperity representative to confirm in writing which continuation rules (federal COBRA or a specific state program) govern your employees, and why.
- File the written answer with your service agreement.
The mistake to avoid is assuming that a 12-person company has no continuation obligation because it sits under the federal threshold. Many states require continuation coverage for smaller groups, and the notice and payment mechanics can differ from federal COBRA. If you have employees in more than one state, repeat the exercise for each one.
You’ll know this step worked when you can state, in one sentence, which rule set applies to each employee group and have a document from Insperity that says so.
Step 2: Find Out in Your Service Agreement Who Administers COBRA and What You Still Own
Open your client service agreement and any benefits addenda, and find the COBRA or continuation coverage language. You’re looking for three things: who sends the notices, who collects premiums from participants, and who answers questions from former employees and their families.
Then ask Insperity to put the task split in writing. Some COBRA work may be handled by Insperity or by a third-party administrator it uses, while other tasks stay with you, such as reporting qualifying events promptly and supplying accurate employee data. Vendor scope differs and can change by contract and plan year, so request confirmation for the current plan year rather than relying on what a colleague remembers from last year.
A simple responsibility sheet helps. List each task (event reporting, election notice, premium collection, eligibility changes, participant questions, records retention) and mark it as Insperity, third-party administrator, or you.
Why the structure matters
A PEO works through co-employment: the PEO and your company share certain employer responsibilities under a contract. That is different from an ASO (administrative services organization), where you remain the sole employer and plan sponsor, and from a payroll-only provider, which typically doesn’t touch benefits administration. Co-employment and plan sponsorship affect who the legal plan administrator is for COBRA purposes, so confirm it for your arrangement rather than relying on general descriptions of how PEOs work. Insperity’s current official materials and your signed agreement are the sources to check.
The mistake to avoid is relying on a sales presentation or a website summary instead of the signed agreement. If the agreement is silent or vague on a task, treat it as unresolved and ask for a written clarification or amendment. For background on how PEOs divide benefits work generally, see our PEO benefits administration guide. [LINK CHECK: PEO benefits administration guide]
Step 3: Map the Qualifying Events and Who Must Report Each One
A qualifying event is a change that would cause a covered person to lose group health coverage and that triggers COBRA rights. A qualified beneficiary is the person who gets those rights, typically the employee, spouse, or dependent child. Per DOL guidance, the qualifying events are:
- Termination of employment, other than for gross misconduct
- Reduction in hours
- The employee’s death
- Divorce or legal separation
- A dependent child ceasing to be a dependent under the plan, such as aging out
- The employee becoming entitled to Medicare
Now sort them by who finds out first. Build a two-column list for your team:
- Events you learn from payroll or management: termination, hours reduction, and often death.
- Events only the family knows: divorce, legal separation, a child aging out. Here the qualified beneficiary generally has a duty to notify the plan, commonly within 60 days, under the plan’s procedures.
For the second group, make sure your employee communications explain how to report these changes and to whom. Your plan documents and Insperity can tell you the exact process.
Set an internal rule that managers tell HR about terminations and hours reductions the same day. Then confirm how HR’s report reaches Insperity: an entry in its system, a form, or a call to a service contact. Write that route down.
The mistake to avoid is entering a termination in payroll and assuming the benefits side was notified automatically. Ask Insperity directly whether a payroll termination triggers the COBRA process or whether a separate report is needed. Don’t infer the answer.
Step 4: Report the Event and Verify the Election Notice Goes Out on Time
DOL guidance sets the standard clock: the employer notifies the plan administrator within 30 days of the qualifying event (such as termination or reduced hours), and the administrator then has 14 days to send the election notice to qualified beneficiaries. Confirm both periods against current DOL materials. If the employer is also the plan administrator, different timing can apply, so check which situation fits your structure based on what you learned in Step 2. Your plan or state rules may also set shorter periods.
Waiting 30 days because you can is a poor habit. Report the event as soon as it happens, using the route you identified in Step 3, and note the date.
Then verify delivery:
- Ask Insperity or its administrator for proof of mailing or delivery, including the address used.
- Keep a copy in the personnel or benefits file.
- During the exit conversation, collect a current mailing address and, if the person agrees, other contact details. Notices sent to a work address or an old apartment are a common failure point.
Tell the departing employee to expect the notice and roughly when. It reduces confusion and gives you an early signal if something goes wrong.
If an employee says no notice arrived
Ask Insperity for the mailing record the same day. Compare the address on file with the one you collected. Late or missing notices can create penalty exposure under ERISA and excise tax rules, so involve employment counsel where the facts suggest a real miss. This guide is informational and not legal advice, and who bears the exposure can depend on your agreement, which is one more reason to have the Step 2 responsibility sheet in hand.
Step 5: Track Election, Payment, and Coverage Deadlines
Once the notice goes out, three clocks run, per DOL guidance:
- Election: qualified beneficiaries have at least 60 days to elect coverage, counted from the later of the date coverage would be lost or the date the notice is provided.
- First payment: 45 days after electing to make the initial premium payment.
- Later payments: a 30-day grace period after each due date.
Ask Insperity who watches these dates and how you can see election status. Request a report or portal view, then test it with a live case rather than a demo. Pick a recent departure and see whether you can tell, without calling anyone, whether the person has elected, paid, or lapsed. If you can’t, agree on a regular status update, such as a weekly list from Insperity or its administrator.
Know the maximum coverage periods too. Generally, coverage can last up to 18 months after termination or reduced hours, and up to 36 months for other events such as death, divorce, or loss of dependent status. Extensions are possible, for example when a qualified beneficiary is determined to be disabled. Verify specifics with the DOL, since extension rules have conditions and notice requirements of their own. Also check whether your state program, if it applies, uses different lengths.
The mistake to avoid is terminating coverage for a missed payment without checking whether the grace period had actually run. A premium that is a few days late may still be timely. Before any cancellation, confirm the due date, the grace period end date, and the payment record with Insperity. Wrongly ending coverage creates problems far costlier than a short wait.
Step 6: Check COBRA Fees, Premium Billing, and Exit Terms Before Renewal
Under DOL guidance, COBRA premiums can generally include up to 102% of the plan’s cost for the coverage, with the extra 2% covering administration. For the disability extension period, the cap can rise to 150%. Ask Insperity for the actual rate your plan charges and whether any administration fee is passed on to the former employee or built into your PEO fees.
Request a current fee schedule in writing. Look for per-participant or per-event COBRA charges, and compare them with what the same service costs from other providers or a standalone COBRA administrator. Don’t rely on figures from articles, forums, or old proposals. Any Insperity-specific fee, service, or limitation should come from its current official materials or your agreement, with a date attached.
Exit terms
Settle this before you need it. Ask Insperity what happens to participants already on COBRA if you leave the PEO:
- Who carries the continuation obligation after the contract ends?
- Does coverage move to a new plan, continue under the old one, or end?
- Which records (notice dates, election forms, payment history) will you receive on exit?
- How long does Insperity keep its records, and can you request them later?
These answers often differ for state continuation participants and for people in an extension period. Getting them in writing before renewal gives you leverage and avoids a gap in coverage or records mid-transition. If you’re still weighing providers, our Insperity comparison page lays out how it stacks up on structure and terms. [LINK CHECK: Insperity comparison page]
Testing the Process With Your Next Real Termination
Once the governing rules, task split, event reporting route, and deadline tracking are confirmed in writing, run the process on your next actual termination. Report the event the same day, confirm the notice date and mailing address, and check the election status at the end of each window. Whatever breaks becomes a specific question for Insperity, and a better-informed renewal conversation.
If you want to see how providers differ on COBRA handling and fees, a side-by-side PEO comparison, such as the one PEOMetrics offers, makes the differences visible. PEOMetrics may receive placement fees from vendors.
Before you sign that PEO renewal, make sure you’re not leaving money on the table.
Many businesses unknowingly overpay because of bundled fees, hidden administrative markups, and contracts designed to limit flexibility. We give you a clear, side-by-side breakdown of pricing, services, and contract terms, so you can see exactly what you’re paying for and choose the option that truly fits your business.