Under an Insperity arrangement, Form I-9 can feel like someone else’s job. It usually isn’t, or at least not entirely. By the end of this guide you’ll know who owns each part of Insperity PEO I-9 verification, how to complete and document the form for a new hire, and how to audit your files.
Before you start, gather your PEO service agreement, your Insperity onboarding materials, and the current Form I-9 and the M-274 Handbook for Employers, both available at USCIS.gov. This guide is informational, not legal advice.
Step 1: Confirm who owns the I-9 under your Insperity agreement
Start with the contract, not assumptions. Under DHS guidance, the worksite employer is generally treated as the employer for I-9 purposes, and a PEO’s role depends on what the agreement assigns to it. Before you rely on that statement, confirm it against the employer responsibilities pages in USCIS I-9 Central and the M-274, since your own situation may turn on details there.
Then read the sections of your service agreement that touch on these topics:
- Employment eligibility verification: does the agreement say who completes, reviews, or supervises Form I-9?
- Record storage: where are I-9s kept, and who can retrieve them?
- Indemnification: what does each party agree to cover if a government agency finds errors?
Don’t assume Insperity’s services include I-9 completion or E-Verify. Check the contract and Insperity’s current materials, and confirm what applies to your account as of November 2026, because service scope can differ by client and change over time.
The mistake to avoid is assuming that co-employment shifts legal liability for I-9 errors to the PEO. It may not, and the contract language matters more than the label. Rather than drawing a legal conclusion yourself, put the question to Insperity in writing: “Under our agreement, which I-9 tasks does Insperity perform, which do we perform, and how is responsibility for errors allocated?” Keep the written answer with your agreement.
Finally, write the answer down as an ownership list: who completes Section 2, who stores the forms, who runs E-Verify if applicable, and who tracks reverification. The remaining steps fill in that list. If you’re still comparing PEOs, a side-by-side look at how providers divide these duties is worth doing before you sign.
Step 2: Choose how your team will complete Section 1 and Section 2
Form I-9 has two parts for every new hire. In Section 1, the employee supplies their own information and attests to their work authorization, no later than the first day of work for pay. In Section 2, the employer or its authorized representative examines the employee’s documents and records them, within three business days of the employee’s first day of work. Confirm both deadlines against the current Form I-9 instructions on USCIS.gov, since the form’s instructions are the controlling source.
An authorized representative is anyone you designate to complete Section 2 on your behalf. That could be an HR lead, a site manager, or a PEO representative acting as your agent. Pick based on who will be physically present with the employee, who has been trained, and who you’re prepared to stand behind, because the employer remains responsible for what that person signs.
Next, decide whether to use an electronic I-9 system. Check Insperity’s website and your account materials for any current electronic I-9 tool, what it does, and whether it’s available to your client tier. Don’t name a product or feature to your team until you’ve confirmed it as of today. If you use any electronic system, review how it handles signatures, audit trails, and retrieval, since those matter later in an inspection.
One mistake comes up often: telling the employee which documents to bring. The employee chooses what to present, either one document from List A, or one from List B plus one from List C. Your instructions should say only that the employee must provide acceptable documents, and point them to the form’s lists. Specifying a document, such as asking for a passport or a Social Security card, can create discrimination exposure.
Document your choices: name the representative, the backup, and the system or paper process in use.
Step 3: Examine documents on the right timeline and in the right way
The default method is physical examination, in person, with the employee present. You check that each document reasonably appears to be genuine and to relate to the person presenting it. You are not expected to be a forensic expert, and you shouldn’t reject documents based on a hunch about the employee’s national origin or citizenship.
Don’t ask for particular documents, and don’t demand copies as a condition of examination. Copying is generally optional, but if you copy, do it consistently for every employee, not selectively. Keep any copies with the corresponding I-9.
The remote alternative
DHS has an alternative procedure that lets certain employers examine documents remotely by live video rather than in person. It’s available only to employers enrolled in E-Verify and in good standing, and it carries specific requirements, including a live video interaction with the employee and retaining copies of the documents. Rules and effective details can change, so read the current alternative procedure guidance on USCIS.gov before using it, and confirm whether it applies to you under your Insperity arrangement. If you aren’t in E-Verify, plan on in-person examination. Employers managing distributed teams may also want to see how PEOs support remote workforce management.
When the employee can’t present documents in time
Sometimes an employee has applied for a replacement document but doesn’t have it yet. The receipt rules allow acceptance of certain receipts for a limited time, and a different set of rules applies to a document that’s been lost, stolen, or damaged. The details, including which receipts qualify and how long they’re valid, are in the M-274, so check there rather than improvising. Record the receipt on the form as instructed and calendar the date the actual document is due.
Step 4: Decide whether E-Verify is part of your process
E-Verify is a separate, web-based system that compares information from Form I-9 with government records. It is not the same thing as completing Form I-9. For many employers it’s voluntary, but it’s mandatory for some federal contractors under their contract terms and for employers in certain states under state law.
Don’t rely on a list from memory. Look up your state’s current requirement, including any thresholds that depend on employer size or industry, on the E-Verify pages of USCIS.gov or with your attorney. If you operate in more than one state, check each one.
If E-Verify applies to you, or you’re choosing to use it, put these questions to Insperity in writing:
- Does Insperity run E-Verify cases on our behalf, or do we?
- Under whose Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) are cases created?
- How are case results, including tentative nonconfirmations, communicated to us, and how fast?
- Who talks to the employee if a case needs follow-up?
The answers determine who needs E-Verify training and who is accountable if a case is handled wrong. Treat them like the I-9 answers from Step 1 and file them with your agreement.
Two mistakes are worth avoiding. First, don’t create a case before Section 2 of the I-9 is complete, since the case is built from the completed form. Second, don’t run cases selectively, for instance only for employees who seem foreign-born. Participating employers generally need to create cases for all new hires consistently, and selective use raises discrimination risk. Confirm the current rules in the E-Verify user manual. For background on how E-Verify fits into broader compliance duties, see our look at PEO comparison and regulatory alignment.
Step 5: Set up storage, retention, and access for your I-9 records
The retention rule is straightforward: keep each Form I-9 for three years after the date of hire, or one year after employment ends, whichever is later. Verify that against USCIS I-9 Central, then set a rule for your process so no one has to recalculate it from scratch. For a terminated employee, that means the end date drives the destruction date, not the hire date.
Decide where originals live. The options are your worksite, an Insperity portal, or both. Each has trade-offs: a portal can centralize forms across locations, while worksite storage keeps them close to the people who completed them. Whichever you choose, ask who controls access and what happens to the records if you leave the PEO. Your agreement’s record storage language from Step 1 should answer part of this, and it’s the part most often skipped. Before signing, it also helps to review how flexible PEO contract terms affect your exit options.
Then test your ability to produce records. When ICE serves a Notice of Inspection, the employer is generally given three business days to produce the I-9s. Confirm that period in the M-274 or ICE guidance. Ask yourself honestly: if a notice arrived this afternoon, who would pull the forms, from where, and how quickly? If the answer depends on a request to Insperity, find out the realistic turnaround now.
One storage mistake makes inspections harder: keeping I-9s inside general personnel files. Store them separately, by employee or in a dedicated file, so you can hand over only what’s requested without exposing unrelated records. If you keep document copies, keep them attached to the matching I-9 and handle them the same way for every employee.
Step 6: Audit your I-9s and correct errors the right way
An internal audit doesn’t have to cover everything at once. Pull a sample, such as a set of recent hires plus some older forms, and check each for common problems:
- Blank fields or missing signatures and dates
- Section 2 completed after the three-business-day deadline
- Expired documents recorded as acceptable
- Missing document titles, numbers, or expiration dates
- An outdated edition of the form
The current edition date is printed on the form itself. Compare it with the version posted on USCIS.gov, because editions are periodically updated and USCIS sets when older ones stop being accepted.
Correcting what you find
Don’t backdate, and don’t overwrite or white out anything. Follow USCIS guidance on corrections: draw a line through the error, enter the correct information, and initial and date the change, using a different color ink so it’s clear it was made later. Attach a brief written explanation of what was fixed and why. Some errors, such as a missing Section 2 for an employee, call for different handling, so check USCIS guidance before improvising, and consider asking counsel about anything substantial.
Compare against Insperity’s records
Request in writing any I-9 audit reports or records that Insperity holds for your company, and compare them against your own files. Gaps, such as a form one of you has and the other doesn’t, are far easier to resolve before an ICE inspection or a reverification deadline than during one. If your PEO offers reporting tools, understanding what PEO analytics and reporting can actually deliver will help you ask for the right records. Keep a log of what you audited, what you found, and what you corrected.
Step 7: Track reverification and expiring work authorization
Reverification happens in Section 3 and applies when an employee’s temporary work authorization, or the document that shows it, expires. Certain Employment Authorization Documents (EADs) are common examples. Other documents don’t need reverification for I-9 purposes. A U.S. passport and a permanent resident card, for instance, are not reverified in Section 3 for this purpose, although a card’s expiration can matter for other reasons. Check the precise rules for each document in the M-274, because it’s easy to get this wrong in both directions.
Build a tickler so expirations don’t surprise you. A spreadsheet or system alert set 90 to 120 days before expiration gives you time to act. That lead time is a practical suggestion, not a legal requirement, so adjust it to how long your process takes. Assign a named owner for the tickler, not a team.
Then settle who does what when an alert fires:
- Who contacts the employee: usually HR or the manager, using a neutral request that doesn’t specify which document to show.
- Who completes Section 3: the employer or authorized representative from Step 2, once the employee provides acceptable documentation.
- Who tells Insperity: payroll and HR records need to match, so agree on how and when Insperity is notified of the update or, if the employee can’t show continued authorization, of any change in status.
Set the deadline for the employee to respond, put it in writing, and keep a record of every contact.
Turning your answers into a one-page checklist
Put each owner and deadline from these seven steps onto a single page: who completes Section 2, who stores the forms, who handles E-Verify, who runs the audit, and who watches expiration dates. Review that checklist with Insperity and with your legal counsel, so the written contract and your daily practice say the same thing.
If you’re approaching a renewal, or still deciding between providers, it also helps to see how different PEOs actually support I-9 and E-Verify tasks. PEOMetrics can set those services side by side with pricing and contract terms, and PEOMetrics may receive placement fees from vendors.
Before you sign that PEO renewal, make sure you’re not leaving money on the table.
Many businesses unknowingly overpay because of bundled fees, hidden administrative markups, and contracts designed to limit flexibility. We give you a clear, side-by-side breakdown of pricing, services, and contract terms, so you can see exactly what you’re paying for and choose the option that truly fits your business.